Some families have traditional recipes they make year after year, but if you want to try something new (or start your own cookie tradition), you may be wondering what the most popular Christmas cookie recipes are. To that end, General Mills put together a guide to the most popular cookies in every state in the U.S. These predictions are based on the Betty Crocker, Pillsbury, and Tablespoon cookie recipes that get the most clicks from eager bakers. Courtesy of General Mills. Try each recipe out for yourself. Each state has distinctive preferences. Still, some cookies get more love than others. Based on this data from General Mills, Peanut Butter Blossoms are the most popular Christmas cookie in the country; it’s the most-visited cookie recipe in seven states, which means it’s the most common favorite cookie in the U.S. That’s a pretty high honor! Other top Christmas cookies include: Sugar Cookie M&M’s Bars (beloved in five states), Sugar Cookie Cutouts (baked often in four states), and Easy Italian Christmas Cookies (adored in four states). Some states have particular preferences for their cookies, too; Ohio, for example, was the only state to call Buckeye Delights its number-one cookie, and New York was the only big fan of Black and White Cookies. In total, 24 cookies made the map—see the full list below, and get ready to drool over delicious cookie recipes. ‘Tis the season, after all.

Sugar Cookie M&M’s BarsEasiest-Ever Russian Tea CakesSugar Cookie CutoutsPeanut Butter BlossomsEasy Spritz CookiesEasy Holiday Oatmeal CookiesEasy Italian Christmas CookiesCream Cheese Pecan CookiesEasy Gingerbread CookiesCandy Cane CookiesMexican Wedding CakesSwedish KringleEasy Christmas Crinkle CookiesNutella Swirled Meringue Cookies2-Ingredient PB-Chocolate TrufflesChristmas SnickerdoodlesEasy Kolaczki CookiesCake Mix Gooey Butter CookiesPeanut Butter-Chocolate CookiesBlack and White CookiesBuckeye DelightsMelted Snowman Sugar CookiesEasy Peanut Butter Cookie CupsGerman Almond Cookies